The relevance of the number of lives in cases of necessity
| dc.coverage | DOI: 10.4067/S0718-00122023000100109 | |
| dc.creator | Miranda Montecinos, Alejandro | |
| dc.date | 2023 | |
| dc.date.accessioned | 05-01-2026 18:20 | |
| dc.date.available | 05-01-2026 18:20 | |
| dc.description | <p>This paper critically analyzes, from a philosophical-legal perspective, the “principle of irrelevance of numbers”, that is, the thesis according to which in a case of necessity it is inadmissible to invoke as justification the weighting according to the number of human lives in conflict. The author tries to show that this principle, in itself, fails to withstand philosophical criticism, and must therefore be abandoned. With this aim, he proceeds as follows. First, the principle of irrelevance of numbers and the conclusions that have been tried to be drawn from it are explained. Second, he shows that these conclusions really confuse the issue of numbers with other morally relevant factors, which can explain them. Third, arguments are presented to prove that numbers are relevant even in the context of a non-consequentialist theory that recognizes the inviolability of the dignity of the person. Fourth, some objections against the relevance of numbers are examined. Finally, the problem of the relevance of numbers as a legal justification is explored.</p> | eng |
| dc.identifier | https://investigadores.uandes.cl/en/publications/d108cc64-7bf9-447f-8637-41bf36fc6e8e | |
| dc.language | spa | |
| dc.rights | info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess | |
| dc.source | vol.29 (2023) nr.1 p.109-123 | |
| dc.subject | Number of lives | |
| dc.subject | necessity | |
| dc.subject | proportionality | |
| dc.subject | Número de vidas | |
| dc.subject | proporcionalidad | |
| dc.subject | necesidad | |
| dc.title | The relevance of the number of lives in cases of necessity | eng |
| dc.title | La relevancia del número de vidas en situaciones de necesidad | spa |
| dc.type | Article | eng |
| dc.type | Artículo | spa |